1
On November 4, 2026, the European Commission adopted its 2027 work program in Brussels, in which it proposed withdrawing the initiative to add “hate speech” and “hate crime” to the list of EU areas of crime set out in Article 83(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), the so-called “EU crimes.”
2
The initiative, announced in 2020 by Ursula von der Leyen and presented in December 2021, required a unanimous decision of the Council of the EU, which could not be reached for almost five years.
3
The project was meant to pave the way for an EU directive that would extend criminalization to, among other things, the grounds of sex and sexual orientation.
4
The Ordo Iuris Institute pointed out the flaws of the proposal from the outset, including its failure to meet the Treaty requirements, its vague definitions, and the threat it posed to freedom of speech. In 2022, Ordo Iuris prepared a legal opinion on the matter, and in 2024, a memorandum for Members of the European Parliament.
5
The Commission’s decision is not final. At the same time, Brussels is considering presenting a directive on combating incitement to violence and hatred online.

On November 4, 2026, the European Commission adopted its 2027 work program in Brussels. Among the 18 proposals slated for withdrawal was the plan to add “hate speech” and “hate crime” to the list of EU areas of crime (the so-called “EU crimes”) set out in Article 83(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU). The proposal in question is Communication COM(2021) 777 “A more inclusive and protective Europe: extending the list of EU crimes to hate speech and hate crime,” listed as item 14 in Annex III to the program. Brussels justifies its decision by the conclusion of work on the file in the Council of the EU, where the required unanimity could not be reached for almost five years. The issue, however, is not closed. In the same document, the Commission announces that it is considering presenting a directive on combating incitement to violence and hatred online.
Main features of the Commission’s proposal
The idea was announced by Commission President Ursula von der Leyen in her State of the Union address of September 16, 2020. At the time, she pledged to extend the EU list of crimes to all forms of “hate speech” and “hate crime,” whether motivated by race, religion, gender or sexuality. The announcement was included in the Commission’s 2021 work program, and on December 9, 2021, the Commission presented to the European Parliament and the Council the relevant communication together with a proposal for a Council decision.
The procedure that Brussels sought to use consists of two steps. Article 83(1) TFEU lists a closed catalog of areas of “particularly serious crime with a cross-border dimension,” in which the Union may establish minimum rules concerning the definition of criminal offenses and sanctions. These include terrorism, trafficking in human beings, sexual exploitation of women and children, illicit drug trafficking, illicit arms trafficking, money laundering, corruption, counterfeiting of means of payment, computer crime and organized crime. The list can be extended only by a unanimous decision of the Council, adopted after obtaining the consent of the European Parliament. Only in a second step could the Commission propose a directive determining what specifically is to be punishable and to what extent. That act would then be adopted under the ordinary legislative procedure, i.e., by a qualified majority in the Council.
As justification, the Commission pointed to the growing number of hate incidents, particularly online, and to the differences between national criminal laws. The current Council Framework Decision 2008/913/JHA requires the punishment of public incitement to violence or hatred on grounds of race, color, religion, descent, or national or ethnic origin. The Commission’s proposal was intended to pave the way for extending criminal-law protection to other grounds, including sex and sexual orientation.
In the following years, the Commission repeatedly called on the Council to take a decision, and its position was supported by the European Parliament. In December 2023, the Commission, together with the High Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, adopted the communication “No place for hate: a Europe united against hatred”, calling for the work to be accelerated. A few weeks later, on January 18, 2024, the European Parliament adopted a resolution prepared by Spanish MEP Maite Pagazaurtundúa of the Renew Europe group, in which it called on the Council to take a decision on the matter before the end of the parliamentary term. Despite this pressure, the member states failed to reach an agreement.
Combating “hate speech” or a tool of censorship?
From the outset, Ordo Iuris pointed to serious flaws in the proposal. In March 2022, the Ordo Iuris Institute prepared a legal opinion on the Commission’s communication, and in January 2024, ahead of the vote in Strasbourg, it sent Members of the European Parliament a memorandum recommending a vote against the resolution in question.
In its publications, Ordo Iuris stressed that the Commission’s plan did not meet the requirements laid down in the Treaty itself. Article 83(1) TFEU covers particularly serious, cross-border offenses, such as terrorism or human trafficking. Ordo Iuris noted that insulting or defaming another person is undoubtedly reprehensible, but it cannot be put on a par with crimes of that kind. Ordo Iuris experts also pointed out that conduct described as “hate speech” is usually local in nature. Moreover, without a precise and generally accepted definition, it is difficult even to reliably demonstrate the upward trend that Brussels invoked.
Ordo Iuris drew attention to the fact that the notions of “hate speech” and “hate crime” are vague and open to arbitrary interpretation. The design of the procedure meant that governments would first have to unanimously recognize them as an EU area of crime before anyone had defined their content. That gap would be filled only by a subsequent directive, adopted by qualified majority. A single state would be unable to block it, and the only remaining safeguard would be the so-called emergency brake under Article 83(3) TFEU.
Ordo Iuris experts pointed to the questionable effectiveness of the proposed solutions, citing the examples of Belgium, France and Spain, which extended their legislation to include, among other things, the grounds of sexual orientation and sex. As they stressed, this did not translate into a significant decrease in the number of acts that the new rules were meant to prevent.
Finally, in the view of Ordo Iuris, the proposal raised concerns in light of the principle of proportionality enshrined in Article 5 of the Treaty on European Union. Criminal law lies at the core of state sovereignty, and every member state already has criminal or civil-law provisions protecting human dignity and honor, as well as provisions implementing Framework Decision 2008/913/JHA. In Poland, these include Articles 256 and 257 of the Polish Criminal Code, which penalize incitement to hatred and insult on grounds of national, ethnic, racial or religious affiliation or lack of religious affiliation, as well as the provisions on defamation and insult (Articles 212 and 216 of the Criminal Code). The arguments for Brussels’ interference in a matter as sensitive as the limits of freedom of expression were therefore weak.
A similar dispute is also under way in Poland. On March 6, 2025, the Sejm, Poland’s lower house of parliament, passed an amendment to the Criminal Code that extended the list of protected grounds in, among others, Articles 256 and 257 of the Criminal Code to include disability, age, sex and sexual orientation. The law never entered into force, however. The President of Poland referred it to Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal under the preventive review procedure, and on September 30, 2025, the Tribunal found the challenged provisions incompatible with the Constitution.
The Commission’s decision: end of the project or a change of strategy?
The announced withdrawal of Communication COM(2021) 777 is part of a review of pending proposals, under which the Commission proposes to drop proposals that lack sufficient support from the co-legislators, show no progress, or no longer reflect the Union’s priorities. Annex III gives as the justification alignment with the conclusion of work on the file in the Council of the EU. The decision is not final. Before taking further steps, the Commission is to take into account the positions of Parliament and the Council.
At the same time, in its work program, the Commission declares that it will further explore options concerning hate crimes committed online. In the annex, it indicates that it is considering presenting a directive on combating incitement to violence and hatred online.
Ordo Iuris comment
The European Commission’s decision seems to confirm what Ordo Iuris had pointed out from the very beginning. The proposal lacked a solid legal basis, and the member states were not prepared to hand Brussels the power to decide on the limits of freedom of speech. At the same time, it must be borne in mind that the announcement of a directive on incitement to hatred online shows that the Commission is looking for another way to achieve the same goal. If Brussels presents a draft of such a directive, the Ordo Iuris Institute will monitor the legislative work and analyze subsequent proposals, because it is the definitions adopted that will determine whether the new provisions serve to combat genuine crimes or may lead to excessive restrictions on freedom of speech – comments Patryk Ignaszczak of the Ordo Iuris Center for International Law.
See also:
- EU Council Conclusions on Racism: From Combating Online “Hate Speech” to the History of Colonialism in Schools
- Ordo Iuris to the UN: Independent Courts Should Decide the Limits of Free Speech
- Freedom of Speech in the Digital Age – A UN Report
- Digital Services Act will combat “hate speech”. EU institutions’ attack on freedom of speech
- Privileging certain groups and restricting freedom of speech in Poland just like in Western countries
Source of cover photo: iStock
