1
The Ordo Iuris Institute is requesting a veto of the Act of October 22, 2026, which allows the President of the UKE to block online content by administrative decision.
2
The blocking orders may cover, among other things, so-called hate speech, and they will be imposed by an authority dependent on the government.
3
The act replicates solutions that the President already vetoed in January 2026.

The Ordo Iuris Institute has asked Polish President Karol Nawrocki to veto the Act of October 22, 2026, amending the Act on the Provision of Services by Electronic Means and certain other acts (the so-called DSA II act, Sejm print no. 2693). The act is meant to implement the EU Digital Services Act (DSA). However, it introduces into Polish law a mechanism for the administrative blocking of online content that goes far beyond what EU law requires.
Should the act enter into force, the President of the Office of Electronic Communications (UKE), who is subordinate to the government, could single-handedly order the blocking of content that the act defines as illegal. In the case of video-sharing platforms, this power would rest with the Chair of Poland’s National Broadcasting Council (KRRiT). The term “illegal content” includes, among other things, so-called “hate speech,” a highly vague and contested notion. There is therefore a risk that an office subordinate to the government could block, for example, statements critical of mass migration.
A rerun of the vetoed act
The DSA II act largely replicates solutions that the government already tried to push through almost a year ago. The President thwarted those attempts at the time by vetoing the then-act (print no. 1757) on January 9, 2026. The veto was a response to, among other things, a request from Ordo Iuris, and in his statement of reasons, the President cited arguments put forward by Ordo Iuris. The government subsequently split the provisions into two acts. The President signed the first one, of September 4, 2026. Ordo Iuris pointed out at the time that the most controversial mechanism, namely the administrative removal of content, had been moved to the second act. It is precisely this act that has now landed on the President’s desk. As Ordo Iuris emphasizes in the analysis it submitted, the act has not remedied the previously identified shortcomings and continues to pose numerous risks.
An arbitrary catalog of “illegal content”
The act lists the offenses to which blocking orders may apply. According to the analysis, their selection is arbitrary, and the explanatory memorandum to the bill does not indicate any criteria. The catalog includes so-called hate speech offenses (Art. 119 § 1, Art. 256 §§ 1–2 and Art. 257 of the Criminal Code). It also includes acts of lesser social harm, such as copyright infringements or violations of the Anti-Tobacco Act. At the same time, the legislature completely omitted the offense of abortion under Art. 152 of the Criminal Code, even though the Internet is one of the main channels of access to illegal abortion.
Ordo Iuris points out that concerns about “hate speech” are not theoretical. In March 2025, Poland’s Prosecutor General issued guidelines on proceedings concerning bias-motivated crimes. Among other things, they recommend cooperation with non-governmental organizations involved in combating hate speech. In turn, a regulation of the Minister of Justice of February 4, 2026, designated 50 prosecutor’s offices to handle such cases.
An express procedure without safeguards
The procedural provisions raise the most concerns. A blocking request may be filed by a prosecutor, the Police, the Border Guard, bodies of the National Revenue Administration, and copyright holders. It may also be filed by any recipient of the service, i.e., de facto anyone. The decision is to be issued within 7 days and, when the applicant is the Police or a prosecutor, within a mere 2 days. The author of the contested content has 48 hours to present his or her position. Following amendments made by Poland’s Senate, this time limit was shortened to 24 hours in cases under Art. 119 § 1 of the Criminal Code. Decisions issued in such cases at the request of the Police or a prosecutor are to be immediately enforceable.
The proceedings are single-instance, and evidence is drastically limited. The examination of witnesses or an expert opinion is admissible only in “particularly complex” cases, and evidence submitted after the deadline is disregarded. In the explanatory memorandum, the legislature openly admitted that it had deliberately excluded the procedural safeguards provided for in the Code of Administrative Procedure. As the analysis points out, this violates the constitutional and EU right to good administration, the essence of which includes, among other things, the right to be heard.
Judicial review only on paper
An objection to a court may be filed against the decision within 14 days. However, the act regulates court proceedings only fragmentarily. It merely refers to a “common court” and “non-contentious proceedings,” without specifying which court has territorial or subject-matter jurisdiction, or whether the case is to be heard by a civil or a criminal division. In some cases concerning “hate speech” (Art. 256 and 257 of the Criminal Code), blocking is to be decided directly by a court. However, the court will have only 14 days to issue its order, which, according to Ordo Iuris, renders the right of defense illusory.
The analysis also draws attention to the register of domains maintained by the President of the UKE. Entry on this “blacklist” takes place without a decision being issued, and Internet service providers have 48 hours to block the listed websites. Nor does the act contain any provisions on compensation for persons whose content has been unlawfully blocked.
Disproportionate interference with freedom of speech
According to Ordo Iuris, the act violates Art. 54 of the Polish Constitution, which guarantees the freedom to express opinions, as well as the principle of proportionality under Art. 31(3). It also violates the standards of the European Convention on Human Rights and the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union. Ordo Iuris recalls the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights in Cengiz and Others v. Turkey, in which the Court emphasized the fundamental importance of the Internet for freedom of expression.
“The act should not enter into force. Not only does it allow flagrant interference with freedom of speech, but it also contains a number of unclear and poorly drafted provisions, especially procedural ones. I believe that this time, too, the President of Poland will refuse to sign it,” says Jędrzej Jabłoński, senior analyst at the Ordo Iuris Institute and author of the analysis. Ordo Iuris has been critical of the proposed solutions from the outset. It has written about them in, among others, the analyses “The EU Didn’t Require It, the Government Did It: On Overregulation and the Risk of Digital Censorship” and “Amendment to the Act on Electronic Services: Excessive State Interference and the Risk of Censorship”.
See also:
- EU Council Conclusions on Racism: From Combating Online “Hate Speech” to the History of Colonialism in Schools
- Artificial Intelligence Under Brussels’ Supervision: What the VLOSE Status Means for ChatGPT
- Freedom of Speech in the Digital Age – A UN Report
- A Ban on “Pathostreaming”: Another Pretext for Internet Censorship in Poland
- Bill Implementing EU’s Digital Services Act Vetoed by Polish President, Citing Arguments Put Forward by Ordo Iuris
Source of cover photo: iStock
