1

The resolution of the Council of Europe’s Congress of Local and Regional Authorities calls on local governments to “mitigate” restrictive national policies, while the explanatory memorandum suggests funding LGBT movement activities in a way that avoids scrutiny by central authorities. These demands may violate the principle of legality (Article 7 of Poland’s Constitution), under which local government bodies act on the basis and within the limits of the law.

2

The report groundlessly attributes to Ordo Iuris lawyers a role in the adoption of resolutions “against LGBT ideology,” relying on a single press article, and inaccurately describes the Local Government Charter of Family Rights without quoting its content.

3

The document places the vetoed Polish amendment to the Education Law alongside a 2013 Russian law and treats low attendance at health education classes as a problem, thereby relativizing parents’ right to raise their children in accordance with their convictions.

4

Following representatives of LGBT organizations, the report’s authors also criticize Poland’s legislative process, including the blocking or vetoing of bills on civil partnerships, hate speech and gender recognition, even though such decisions lie beyond the Congress’s mandate.

5

The Congress delegation did not meet with the local governments it criticizes, with parents’ organizations or with the Ordo Iuris Institute, and the non-binding documents, as so-called soft law, may influence the decisions of municipal and county councils in Poland.


 


On October 28, at its 51st session in Strasbourg, the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe (hereinafter: the Congress) adopted Resolution 537 (2026) and Recommendation 560 (2026), based on a report entitled “Free to speak, free to meet: guaranteeing the rights of LGBTI persons in local communities”. The document is devoted to freedom of expression and freedom of assembly with regard to gatherings organized by the LGBT movement, and to the role of local and regional authorities in protecting them. It also sets out demands addressed to local governments concerning, among other things, parades, funding for organizations, education and data collection, and devotes a separate chapter to Poland.

The report names Ordo Iuris, falsely presenting its lawyers as having “been behind” the declarations on alleged “LGBT-free zones” (in reality, these were resolutions by which local governments committed themselves not to promote the ideology of the LGBT movement). The rapporteurs are Helen Belcher, a transgender activist and Liberal Democrat politician from the United Kingdom, and Gudrun Mosler-Törnström, a former member of the Salzburg Landtag for the Social Democratic Party of Austria (SPÖ).

What is the Congress and what does the report contain?

The Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe is one of the Council of Europe’s institutions, responsible for strengthening local and regional democracy. It comprises 612 elected representatives of more than 150,000 local and regional authorities from 46 member states, sitting in two chambers. Its activities are based on the Charter of the Congress, annexed to Statutory Resolution CM/Res(2020)1 of the Committee of Ministers.

The three parts of the report differ in nature. The explanatory memorandum contains the rapporteurs’ findings and assessments and is submitted for information. The draft resolution and draft recommendation are put to a vote. The resolution is the Congress’s position addressed to local and regional authorities. The recommendation asks the Committee of Ministers to call on member states to take specific actions; the Committee of Ministers decides on its further course, and any implementation is up to the states themselves.

What does the resolution recommend to local governments?

The first part of the document contains the resolution of the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe, prepared by the Committee on Social Inclusion and Human Dignity. In this part, the Congress refers to Article 10 (freedom of expression) and Article 11 (freedom of assembly and association) of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (hereinafter: the Convention), the case law of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter: the ECtHR), recommendations of the Committee of Ministers, resolutions of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe and earlier Congress acts, including Resolution 471 (2021) on the situation of persons identifying with the demands of the LGBT movement in Poland. The Congress expresses concern that the rights of such persons are allegedly under growing pressure in some member states, and that the exercise of freedom of expression and assembly by representatives of these minorities is sometimes portrayed as a threat to traditional values.

The core part calls on local and regional authorities to take “specific and proactive measures” in support of these freedoms, including mitigating restrictive national policies, authorizing parades without deliberate hindrance and ensuring their protection, ensuring access to “objective information and education” on sexual orientation and so-called gender identity, supporting LGBT organizations, designating equality focal points and training public sector employees, participating in networks of local governments, and collecting data on violence and so-called hate speech.

Recommendation 560 (2026) of the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe, found later in the document, repeats the grounds and the diagnosis set out in the resolution. In it, the Congress asks the Committee of Ministers to call on national authorities to ensure that law and practice comply with the Convention and ECtHR case law, to provide local governments with autonomy, competences and resources in line with the principles of the European Charter of Local Self-Government, and to refrain from introducing legislation obliging local governments to restrict the freedom of expression and assembly of persons identifying with the LGBT movement. States are also to strengthen equality bodies and ombudsman institutions, coordinate the actions of different levels of government in areas such as policing and education, and establish national systems for collecting data on violence and so-called hate speech against persons identifying with these organizations’ demands. In addition, the Committee of Ministers is to recognize the role of local governments in protecting the “rights of LGBTI persons” and continue involving the Congress in this work.

Explanatory memorandum

The following pages contain the explanatory memorandum, the most extensive part of the document. It starts from the thesis that the LGBT movement’s freedom of expression and assembly is under threat in many parts of Europe, as allegedly evidenced by bans on parades, hostility toward persons and organizations identifying with these demands, and attacks in the media (para. 1). The legal section recalls the ECtHR’s case law on Articles 10 and 11 of the Convention, including the Grand Chamber judgment in Macatė v. Lithuania of January 23, 2023 (paras. 8–13). The memorandum then discusses bans on assemblies, security, education, the media and the situation of non-governmental organizations (paras. 23–48), the situation in Poland based on the Congress delegation’s visit to Warsaw on January 27–28, 2026 (paras. 49–61), and the ways in which local governments can counteract restrictive national policies (paras. 62–82). The whole closes with conclusions (paras. 83–86) and two appendices.

Poland and Ordo Iuris under the Congress’s scrutiny

The report states that some 100 local governments, mainly in southeastern Poland, adopted acts described as resolutions on so-called LGBT-free zones and “Family Rights Charters,” containing provisions which, in the authors’ view, were intended to limit access to municipal funding and support for the “human rights protection for LGBTI persons.” These documents were allegedly adopted as part of a concerted effort by supporters of the then ruling coalition (para. 50).

In a footnote, the report describes Ordo Iuris as a Polish ultra-Catholic center that litigates and lobbies for the incorporation of ultra-conservative views into law in Poland and in Europe. It adds that the Ordo Iuris Institute’s lawyers were behind the declarations on so-called LGBT-free zones and other initiatives aimed at curtailing equality laws (footnote 63). The document notes that all the resolutions have been withdrawn or repealed, including by the courts (paras. 55 and 82).

It is worth noting that the claim about the role of Ordo Iuris is untrue, and its sole source is a press article of June 22, 2021 (footnote 63). On this matter, the report does not cite any document or ruling and does not distinguish between two types of acts. The resolutions “against LGBT ideology” were adopted by municipal and county councils; the Ordo Iuris Institute was not their author. The Local Government Charter of Family Rights of April 18, 2019, is a separate document, drafted by Ordo Iuris experts in cooperation with more than twenty civil society organizations. The terms “LGBT persons” or “LGBT ideology” do not appear even once in its text. The Charter concerns parents’ rights in schools, municipal social policy and good business practices, and includes proposals to establish a Family Rights Ombudsman and to assess the impact of local law on the family.

The report’s description of the Charter is inaccurate. The Charter provides that programs of cooperation with civil society organizations should “take into account the principle of strengthening the family and marriage and exclude the funding of projects that undermine these values,” and in particular provides for “excluding the possibility of allocating public funds and public property to projects that undermine the constitutional identity of marriage as a union of a woman and a man or the autonomy of the family” (Part II of the Charter). The criterion is the subject matter of the project, not the applicant, and the legal basis is Article 18 of Poland’s Constitution. The report does not quote the Charter and does not indicate which version of it it is assessing. In Appendix I, it goes even further, wrongly attributing to the Charters a rejection of discussion of LGBTI issues and of support for local actors that address them.

The report also contains inconsistencies. In para. 50, the number of local governments is given as “some 100,” whereas in Appendix I it is 80. The report dates Warsaw’s “LGBT+ Declaration” to 2020, while also stating that it was this document that triggered the adoption of the local resolutions (para. 53). The Local Government Charter of Family Rights, which was a response to that document, dates from April 2019, however. The Ordo Iuris Institute has never concealed the reactive nature of the Charter, describing it as a “moral response” to the ideological declarations of some local governments (Questions and Answers, answer 1). The report itself admits that the declarations and charters in question were “not enforceable and largely symbolic,” although, following the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights, it adds that they had an impact on the situation of so-called LGBTI persons (para. 51).

Local governments versus national law

The enigmatic demand to mitigate restrictive national policies, contained in the resolution, is developed in the memorandum. In this part, the document allows that this may put local government officials in conflict with national law (para. 22), and presents local governments as “key actors” in mitigating the impact of restrictive national legal frameworks (para. 62). As an example, it cites the Mayor of Budapest, who, after a statutory ban on the parade, held it under the label of “municipal events” (para. 67). It also states that in times of state hostility, municipalities may have to be creative to avoid negative national scrutiny, and that cultural or social funds may indirectly support LGBT movement activities without a separate, politically sensitive budget line (para. 69, footnote 77).

In this context, it should be noted that such demands may conflict with national legal orders. In Poland’s case, the principle of legality, enshrined in Article 7 of the 1997 Constitution of the Republic of Poland, means that local government bodies act on the basis and within the limits of the law, and their competences are defined by statutes. Thus, if a statute violates the Convention, the proper course is to pursue legal remedies before national courts or to amend the statute, not to have it “mitigated” by municipal bodies. The report does recognize this problem, pointing out that the state is responsible for violations of the Convention involving local governments and that solutions must be sought at that level (para. 21), and that in Poland significant reforms must come from the government because of the country’s centralized system (para. 60). It also notes that in 2025, Poland’s Commissioner for Human Rights (Ombudsman) did not receive any formal complaints about serious problems related to discrimination against so-called LGBT persons, including in connection with equality marches (para. 59).

Moreover, the report does not confine itself to local government matters. In the part devoted to Poland, following representatives of LGBT organizations, it criticizes the fact that bills on civil partnerships, on hate crimes and hate speech, and on gender recognition were blocked, vetoed by the President of Poland or put on hold (para. 60). Citing interviewees and other sources, it also repeats the opinion that the lack of progress stems from the government’s fear of voters’ reactions ahead of the 2027 parliamentary elections (para. 61). These decisions belong to the legislature and to the President of Poland, acting within the constitutional separation of powers. Assessing them hardly falls within the mandate of the Congress, whose task is to strengthen local and regional democracy, and in practice it turns the report into an instrument of pressure on the national legislative process.

Education and parental rights

According to the resolution, education on sexual orientation and so-called gender identity is also to include school curricula, in line with local governments’ competences. The memorandum describes with concern the Slovak constitutional amendment adopted in September 2025, which makes students’ participation in comprehensive sexuality education conditional on parental consent (para. 33), the Italian bill banning classes on gender in kindergartens and primary schools, and British guidance recommending that schools not teach as fact that every person has a so-called gender identity (para. 35, footnote 50).

Particularly telling, however, is the company in which the report places these examples. As the first example of measures restricting access to information on issues related to the LGBT movement’s demands, the report cites the 2013 Russian law prohibiting the dissemination of information about “non-traditional sexual relations,” and then lists the Hungarian law of 2021 and the Georgian law of 2024 (para. 34). Alongside them, it places the Italian bill and the British guidance (para. 35), and among the other “legislative attempts of this kind” it mentions the 2022 Polish amendment to the Education Law, concerning, among other things, the rules governing the activities of outside organizations in schools, which was vetoed by the President of Poland (para. 36). The report neither describes its content nor explains what it has in common with the Russian law. Yet the dispute over the terms on which outside entities may conduct classes with children concerns the organization of the education system and the right of parents to raise their children in accordance with their own convictions (Article 48(1) of Poland’s Constitution), not the freedom of expression of adults.

Of particular interest is that, in the part devoted to Poland, the authors consider attendance at the optional health education classes in the 2025/2026 school year to be disappointingly low (para. 61): around 40 percent in primary schools and 10 percent in general secondary schools (footnote 72). The document notes that many parents withdrew their children from these classes and, citing the delegation’s interlocutors during its visit to Poland, points to the need to convince parents of their value (para. 61). Appendix I states that “parental rights are not unlimited” and that the protection of minors does not justify restricting LGBTI-inclusive education (Appendix I).

Funding for advocacy organizations and equality structures

Among the entities that local governments are to support politically, logistically and financially, the resolution explicitly lists “non-governmental advocacy organisations,” as well as meeting spaces, community centers and cultural institutions. The memorandum speaks of allocating funds to LGBTI associations (para. 85). The document justifies this demand by the difficult financial situation of these organizations: citing ILGA data from 2021, it indicates that most of them have small budgets and depend on short-term grants and foreign donors (para. 46). In large cities, local government support is sometimes combined with broader budgets for equality and social policy or with projects financed from European Union funds (para. 47).

The second pillar is to be equality structures in local government offices. The resolution provides for designating “equality focal points” to maintain sustained engagement with the LGBTI community, as well as training for local government employees, teachers and local police. As a model, the memorandum presents Polish solutions: the Council for Equal Treatment in Kraków, the Social Diversity Department and the Equal Treatment Office in Wrocław, and the Plenipotentiary of the Mayor of Wrocław for Equal Treatment, appointed in April 2023 (para. 53). Similar structures in Poznań, Łódź and Świdnica are said to have been particularly important during the period of restrictive national policy (para. 65).

Hate speech, data collection and freedom of expression

The report cites the judgment in Vejdeland and Others v. Sweden of February 9, 2012, in which the ECtHR found sanctions for distributing leaflets, which the document describes as homophobic, to be permissible even in the absence of explicit incitement to violence (para. 10). It identifies as a challenge the clear definition of which statements constituting hate speech should be subject to criminal liability (para. 41), and regards disinformation, spread also by local politicians, as a problem (para. 37). It justifies the data collection demands contained in the resolution and the recommendation by an increase in violence, while admitting that some of the findings are based on anecdotal reports (para. 3) and that the data are inconsistent and may partly reflect a greater willingness to report incidents (para. 43).

In assessing this direction, it should be emphasized that the use of broad and imprecise categories such as “disinformation,” together with efforts to expand the range of statements subject to criminal liability, threatens to have a chilling effect on the debate about marriage, upbringing and sex, and consequently endangers the freedom of expression guaranteed, among others, by Article 10 of the Convention. The report itself recalls that, according to the ECtHR, debate on issues concerning the situation of persons identifying with the LGBT lobby is relevant to democratic discourse (para. 8). The protection of freedom of expression must therefore also cover statements critical of the LGBT movement’s demands.

Assemblies and counter-demonstrations

The report recalls that the ECtHR has consistently held bans on parades to be a violation of Article 11 of the Convention (para. 12). It cites the judgment in Bączkowski and Others v. Poland of May 3, 2007, which found a violation of Articles 11, 13 and 14 of the Convention in connection with the refusal to authorize a parade in Warsaw in 2005 (footnote 20). It should be noted, however, that the report mentions counter-demonstrations only as gatherings of the far right or of anti-LGBTI groups inciting violence (para. 29) and as a pretext for bans, including in Poland and Hungary (para. 30), while ignoring peaceful assemblies.

The way the report was prepared also raises doubts. In Warsaw, the Congress delegation met with the Association of Polish Cities, the Office of the Commissioner for Human Rights, the department for equal treatment at the Chancellery of the Prime Minister, the Council of Europe office, and with the Campaign Against Homophobia, the Love Does Not Exclude Association and QueerMuzeum (Appendix II). It did not, however, talk to the local governments whose actions it criticizes, to parents’ organizations or to entities holding different views, including the Ordo Iuris Institute, which is named in the report. The rapporteur team included no representatives of the center-right and right-wing groups (EPP/CCE, ECR and PfE).

Conclusion

The Congress’s report must be assessed critically. Although it formally concerns the role of local governments in protecting freedom of expression and assembly, in practice it is above all a set of specific political demands prepared from a single perspective. The selection of examples and assessments leaves no doubt as to the authors’ intentions: strengthening the role of parents in schools and counter-demonstrations are presented as threats, while the vetoed Polish amendment to the Education Law is lined up alongside Russian legislation.

Particularly troubling is the fact that the document encourages local governments to “mitigate” restrictive national policies and to fund activities in such a way as to avoid scrutiny by central authorities, while at the same time, following interlocutors from LGBT organizations, it passes judgment on Poland’s legislative process and the decisions of the President of Poland. The report’s authors thereby take on the role of participants in a domestic political dispute. This also affects the document’s reliability: the most serious accusation against the Ordo Iuris Institute was based on a single press article, and the Local Government Charter of Family Rights itself was described without quoting its content. The resolution and the recommendation are not binding, but as so-called soft law they may become an argument in disputes in Polish municipal and county councils and thus influence practice. For this reason, local government officials must not disregard these documents, nor allow them, under the guise of non-binding recommendations, to influence the decisions of local authorities and restrict their autonomy.

Patryk Ignaszczak – analyst at the Ordo Iuris Center for International Law

See also:

Source of cover photo: iStock

Support us